Aweh, Dear Ruminants and Groupies
The stuff we genuinely believe
There are people who genuinely believe they can communicate with the dead. Some people genuinely believe that everything happens for a reason. Some people genuinely believe that nationalising large chunks of the South African economy will improve the lot of the poor.
I find all three propositions batshit crazy.
My own belief system, on the other hand, is a carefully constructed intellectual edifice founded on evidence, reason, scientific principles, economic literacy and a sophisticated appreciation of the complexities of human society. Its development has benefited enormously from my considerable intellectual capacity and my remarkable ability to interrogate evidence without prejudice.
It is, quite obviously, better than yours.
Someone may genuinely believe that nationalisation will improve the lot of the poor whilst also recognising the wonderful employment opportunities it creates for themselves, their relatives and their political comrades. They may see absolutely nothing wrong with this. It’s all part of transformation, after all.
The fact that a belief system is immensely convenient to its adherents doesn’t mean they don’t genuinely believe in it.
Unfortunately, there is the rather irritating matter of objective reality. And objective reality doesn’t give a shit what any of us believe.
So, we’ve nationalised a mine, and it’s losing money. No problem. Subsidise it. We nationalised the bloody thing to look after the workers, not to enrich capitalist bastards.
Where does the money come from? Tax the rich. Running out of rich people? Perhaps Elon Musk can help. Failing that, print some money. What the hell is the point of having a Reserve Bank if it can’t provide money when we need it?
Inflation? Introduce price controls. Shortages? Establish a government agency to distribute essential goods, thereby creating further wonderful employment opportunities for relatives and political comrades.
The beauty of this particular belief system is that every new problem creates an opportunity to implement more of it.
At what point do we reconsider the original idea? Or does every successive failure simply reinforce the conviction that we haven’t gone far enough?
Some of the most spectacular fuck-ups in human history have been perpetrated by people who genuinely believed they were making the world a better place. Give them sufficient political power and access to other people’s money and the scope for mischief is almost unlimited.
The stuff we convince ourselves we believe
Now for some uncomfortable introspection.
I believe in meritocracy. I’ve done rather well in life, and my belief system allows me to attribute much of my success to my intelligence, hard work and good judgement.
How fucking convenient.
Had I spent the last 40 years working as a security guard for a pittance, would I be quite so enthusiastic about meritocracy? Would I be quite so dismissive of politicians promising to redistribute the wealth accumulated by people like me?
I also believe that South Africans are overtaxed and that the government should be smaller. It’s a little disconcerting how neatly my supposedly objective analysis of the world aligns with my personal financial interests.
Politicians convince themselves that giving politicians more power is good for society. Academics convince themselves that spending more money on their particular area of research is desperately important for humanity.
There is a big difference between looking at the evidence and deciding what to believe and deciding what you want to believe and then looking for the evidence.
Naturally, I believe I do the former. It’s the other bastards who do the latter.
The stuff we pretend to believe
In 1995, an economist called Timur Kuran published a book with the splendid title Private Truths, Public Lies. He explores what he calls preference falsification: a fancy academic term for misrepresenting what we privately think because it suits us to do so.
How many South African politicians genuinely believe that the state would do a better job of running our mines and banks? And how many simply recognise the opportunities for themselves and their political networks?
If professing a belief in state ownership improves your prospects of becoming chairman of a newly nationalised mining company, there is a compelling reason to profess that belief. Whether you actually believe it is neither here nor there.
Anyone who has spent three decades in the corporate world, as I have, will be familiar with the phenomenon.
The CEO comes up with a spectacularly stupid idea. The executives enthusiastically endorse it, consultants are employed, budgets are allocated, and people get promoted for implementing it.
Over a beer on Friday afternoon, some of those same executives will happily explain why it’s a spectacularly stupid idea.
Meanwhile, the CEO, reassured by the enthusiastic endorsement of his highly paid executives, is more convinced than ever of his own brilliance.
Everybody’s happy.
You don’t actually need people to believe in a stupid idea for an entire corporation, or indeed a country, to devote enormous resources to pursuing it. You simply need to make it sufficiently rewarding for people to pretend to believe in it.
And when that irritating bastard called objective reality eventually makes an appearance, many of those involved will have retired, been promoted or moved on to their next lucrative opportunity.
There is, after all, quite a decent living to be made out of other people’s stupid belief systems.
The stuff we dare not admit we believe
Sometimes we keep our mouths shut not because there is something to be gained, but because there is something to be lost.
Those of us who lived through apartheid might reflect on the extraordinary disappearance of its supporters. Judging by conversations with white South Africans today, one wonders how the National Party ever managed to win an election.
Apparently, nobody supported the bloody thing.
Some genuinely changed their minds. Others privately opposed apartheid but lacked the courage to say so. And some presumably still harbour much the same beliefs but have worked out that articulating them is no longer socially acceptable.
Kuran uses this phenomenon to help explain why the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe took so many people by surprise. People privately thought the system was crap but feared the consequences of saying so. Their silence helped sustain the impression that everybody else supported it.
Once enough people started saying what they actually thought, the whole thing unravelled with astonishing speed.
How many ANC politicians privately think that cadre deployment has been an unmitigated disaster? How many senior executives think the corporate strategy they’re implementing is fundamentally stupid? What would happen to their careers if they said so tomorrow morning?
It’s all very well to extol the virtues of intellectual integrity when somebody else’s livelihood is at stake.
I can recall occasions in my own corporate career when I weighed up the merits of expressing an honestly held view against the merits of continued gainful employment.
Intellectual integrity is a wonderful thing. So is a monthly salary.
What intrigues me is how many of our apparently widely held beliefs would survive an outbreak of complete anonymity and brutal honesty.
Perhaps we would discover that considerably fewer people believe the shit we collectively spend so much time, money, and effort perpetuating.
Until next time
Bruce
